A new website should bring in more enquiries. Too often, the opposite happens: the new site looks great, launches on a Monday, and by the end of the month the phone is quieter than before. Nothing was wrong with the design. The old pages simply vanished from Google, taking their rankings with them.

This checklist covers how to tell whether you really need a redesign, what to keep from your current site, and the steps that protect your rankings and leads while everything changes.

Signs it’s time for a redesign

  • It’s hard to use on a phone: tiny text, buttons too close together, sideways scrolling.
  • It’s slow, especially on mobile data.
  • You can’t update it without calling a developer, so it’s out of date.
  • It doesn’t say what you do now: your services, team or location have changed.
  • Visitors don’t get in touch: there’s no clear next step, or the forms are broken.
  • It’s insecure or unsupported: old software that no longer gets updates.

If only one or two of these apply, a refresh might be enough: new copy, better calls to action, a speed fix. If most of them apply, a rebuild usually costs less in the long run than patching.

What to keep from your old website

  • Pages that rank on Google and bring in visitors, even if they look dated.
  • Your page addresses (URLs), wherever they still make sense.
  • Content that answers real questions: FAQs, guides, service details customers actually read.
  • Anything other sites link to: those links are a big part of why Google trusts you.
  • Your analytics history, so you can compare before and after.

The redesign checklist

Before you start

  1. Write down the goal in one sentence, such as “more quote requests from Gozo” or “easier to update our menu”.
  2. Record a baseline: monthly visitors, enquiries, calls and your top search terms in Google Search Console.
  3. List every page on the current site, with its address and how many visits it gets.
  4. Mark each page: keep as it is, rewrite, merge, or remove.
  5. Collect your content and logins: domain, hosting, Google Business Profile, analytics, email.

While it’s being built

  1. Design for phones first, then check it on desktop.
  2. Give every page one clear next step: call, WhatsApp or a short form.
  3. Rewrite the copy around customers’ questions, not your company history.
  4. Build on a private test address, never on the live site, and keep it hidden from Google.

At launch

  1. Redirect every old address that changed to its closest new page (a 301 redirect), not all to the homepage.
  2. Check page titles and descriptions on every important page.
  3. Test every form and make sure the emails actually arrive.
  4. Make the site visible to Google: a common mistake is launching with the test setting that hides it.
  5. Submit the new sitemap in Google Search Console.
  6. Update your Google Business Profile, social profiles and directory listings if anything changed.

After launch

  1. Watch Search Console for pages Google can’t find (404 errors) and fix the redirects.
  2. Compare visitors and enquiries with your baseline after a month, then after three.
  3. Keep it updated and backed up, so you don’t end up redesigning again for the same reasons.

Redesign or rebuild?

A redesign changes how the site looks. A rebuild replaces what’s underneath. If the problems are about looks and words, a redesign can do. If the site is slow, insecure or impossible to update, putting a new design on top only hides the problem for a while. In that case, rebuilding it properly is the cheaper choice over a few years.

Questions to ask before you hire someone

Whoever rebuilds your site, these answers tell you whether your rankings and enquiries are safe in their hands:

  • How will you handle redirects from my old pages? (The only good answer is a page-by-page plan.)
  • Will I be able to edit text, photos and pages myself afterwards?
  • Who owns the domain, the hosting account, the design files and the content?
  • How do you test the site on phones before launch?
  • What happens after launch: who updates it, backs it up and fixes problems?
  • Can I see the site on a test address before it replaces the current one?

If any answer is vague, ask again. A redesign is one of the few projects where a small oversight, like forgotten redirects or a form that sends to an old email address, can quietly cost you customers for months.

FAQ

Redesign questions

Didn't find your question? Ask us directly. We reply within two working days, faster on WhatsApp.
WhatsApp Email
Will a website redesign hurt my Google rankings?

It can, if pages disappear or change address without redirects. Keep the pages that rank, redirect every address that changes, and check Google Search Console after launch, and a redesign usually helps rankings instead.

How often should a business website be redesigned?

There’s no fixed schedule. Redesign when the site stops doing its job: it’s hard to use on phones, slow, out of date, or not bringing in enquiries. Keeping it updated in between makes big redesigns less frequent.

Should I keep my old website content?

Keep anything that brings in visitors, answers real questions or has links from other sites, and rewrite it if needed. Remove or merge pages that are outdated, thin or duplicated.

What's a 301 redirect?

A permanent redirect that sends visitors and Google from an old page address to its new one. It tells Google the page moved rather than disappeared, so most of its ranking carries over.